Module 9.7 What Does It Really Mean?
Module Introduction
One of the goals of any communication strategy is to make sure that all the
messages that are released are structured in such a way as to reduce, the possibility of
misinterpretation. The key to avoiding misinterpretation is to make sure that the meaning
is obvious.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
1. What Does It Really Mean?
Almost anything that anyone says can have more than one meaning. While this
makes word play and puns possible, it can complicate doing project/programme purpose. project/programme purpose needs to be
conducted in simple language, with everyone involved in a project/program in complete agreement
about what the language defining the project/program actually means.
Sometimes languageboth spoken and writtenis misinterpreted
accidentally. Sometimes it is done on purpose. Sometimes writing is so vague and a
piece so poorly written or complicated that it is impossible to figure out exactly what
the writer was actually trying to communicate.
One of the goals of any communication strategy is to make sure that all
the messages that are released are structured, written, and presented in such a way as to
reduce the possibility of misunderstanding and misinterpretation.
The key to minimizing misinterpretation is to make sure that the meaning is as
obvious as possible. Here, careful thought and simplicity are the keys, as is showing your
message to others in the organization to see if your meaning is clear. As anyone who has ever
read even a few project/programme purpose documents or government regulations knows, many executives and
bureaucrats seem to be incapable of saying anything simply.
Some are vague because they do not know what is expected of them. Others are vague
because they are afraid of ever saying anything that takes a organization stand or position on
anything. Others do not want anyone to know what is actually going on. Still others do not
really know how to communicate simply. There are even those who take pride in their
ability to obfuscate.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
2. What Does It Really Mean? (Continued)
One of the reason there are so many books available on how to operate computers and
how to use specific software programssuch as word processing, spreadsheets, and for
creating and using graphics, photography, video, and animationis that the user
manuals that come with the computers and the software programs themselves are often
unintelligible.
The people who write them either do not know howor careto explain
themselves simply. What frequently happens is
that there is an over use of jargon when people try to explain what they want
others to understand. Jargon is an
example of the COIK principle Clear Only If Know. When you know the jargon,
the meaning is very clear; if not, then the meaning is a mystery.
Like lawyers, politicians, bureaucrats, doctors, academics, and the people who
write computer manuals, are often also known for insisting that they show off their
vocabulary, and how convoluted they can make their sentences, even if their audience doesnt
know what they are talking about. In other words, rather than writing clearly, many
people are more interested in seeming educated or forget that they are using jargon that
others dont understand. Heres one example of academic verbal overkill
taken from an Internet site (http://www.write-an-essay.com/essay_jargon.html),
that helps students write more clearly:
In situationist projects, the methods
of instrumental science are inverted and replaced with a disturbing desire to make people
suffer in order to experience the sensual, essentially alienated, narcissistic aspects of
modern life. The poetics of weathering, mortality, etc, became, in situationist practice,
as reactionary nihilist lament upon the death of reciprocity between individual and common
creativity.
Academics can often get away with writing like that because they grade their students; their students do not grade them. In the organizational world, however, we are graded by our action sponsors/beneficiaries, beneficiaries, stockholders, and partners. If they dont understand what we are saying, we can do worse than flunk. We can wind up out of project/programme purpose and unemployed.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
3. Simplicity
As French author Nicolas Boileau put it:
What is conceived well is expressed clearly, and the words to say it will arrive with ease.
Just how does one manage to do that? Here are six tips to help you keep your
writing simple, and make it simple for your readers, listeners, or viewers to follow:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
4. Simplicity
in Action
Keeping your writing simple will help your readers better understand what is the message you are trying to get across. Here are some examples of simplicity that have changed the world.
Albert Einsteins theory of relativity states that energy
is the same as mass, and that energy can be turned into mass and mass can be turned into
energy. One of the most important concepts of modern physics, it expresses the
relationship between energy (E), mass (M), and the speed of light (C),
E=MC2
The Pythagorean theorem, one of the basic tenets of mathematics, is 20 words:
The sum of the squares of the sides of a right triangle is equal to the
square of the hypotenuse.
Archimedes Principle about buoyancy, which explains why steel ships filled with cement dont sink, can be summed up in 21 words:
The buoyant force on a submerged object is equal to the weight of the fluid
that is displaced by that object.
The 10 Commandments, the basis of morality for all of the worlds Jews and Christians, are 179 words long.
The
How many words does it take for:
· Your organization to explain its pricing policies?
· The Common Market to explain policies on importing and exporting dairy products?
· The government to explain its tax laws?
One of the hallmarks of good writing is simplicity. It is best to keep your writing simple to allow your audience to best grasp your message.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
5. Be Specific
While it is important to avoid jargon and use words and phrases that the
people you are addressing to understand, it is equally important to be specific and
describe exactly what you mean. You do not want to write over your audiences head,
nor on the other hand, treat them like idiots. This is why it is so important to know some
key points about your audience:
1.
What they
know, including their understanding of any jargon;
2.
What they dont
know;
3.
What they are
interested in.
If, for example, you were to write an article about snow for people who had never
skied, or even seen snow for that matter, you would have to define a number of basic
terms. If you were to write a similar article for a group of experienced cross-country
skiers, you would assume that your readers already knew the basics. You could use words-jargon-that
skiers use to describe snow conditions without having to define those terms, words such as
corn snow, pack, machine groomed, roto-tilled, mogul, and powder.
If you were to write about snow for Eskimos, you would be dealing with ways of
describing it unique to their culture and language. Anthony C. Woodbury, Ph.D. a
professor of linguistics at the
Once that snow hits the ground, they have five more words for it. Nutaryuk
means fresh snow, and aniu refers to all snow on groundboth fresh and old. Muruaneq
is soft deep snow, getrar is the crust that forms on fallen snow, and its qanisqineq
when it is floating on water but hasnt yet turned into ice
for which there are
even more words.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
6. Perception
Is Reality
For all
practical purposes, when it comes to what others think about things, about us and about
what we do, about everything for that matter, perception is their realityeven
when the perception is mistaken.
If you give children a complicated book and make them read it, for example, they
will understand some of the words. When you ask them what it was about, they will tell you
what they understood. Their understanding is what the book was aboutto them. It
becomes their reality. Here are a few examples of how children have misinterpreted what
they have been taught, taken from collections of student bloopers published on the
Internet at http://www.inspiringteachers.com/inspirations/kids/:
The same thing happens when adultsincluding stockholders and beneficiariesmisunderstand
what you write. Regardless of what you were trying to say, whatever they get out of itthat
is, how they perceive itbecomes their reality, and you and your organization have to live
with it.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
7.
First Things First
Before we can communicate anything, we have to know what the people we are
trying to communicate with already knowor what they think they knowand how
that knowledge is getting in the way of the message we are trying to send them.
If, for example, you are trying to sell a widget to people who are convinced that
this product is really a dangerous machine that will explode and hurt them, you have to
first convince them that widgets really are perfectly safe before you can even think about
selling them one.
Past informationhistory and cultureshapes current perception.
That perception must be taken into account when shaping a message designed to
either reinforce or dispel the ideas or attitudes people already have.
If to your potential market the word widget means danger, until you
change that perception, thats all the word widgets will ever mean. It does
not matter what else you say about widgets, whether you say it in a speech, news release,
through an expensive advertising campaign, or in interviews on radio or television. There
are many examples of this type of perception creating difficulties for organizations .
There are numerous examples of this type of perception creating difficulties; here are
just a couple:
Coors Beer
used its slogan, Turn it Loose, into Spanish.
Unfortunately it translated as suffer from diarrhea.
Pepsis
Come Alive with the Pepsi Generation translated into Pepsi Brings Your
Ancestors Back from the Grave in Chinese.
Not only must you speak in terms that your audience will understand, you have to
understand their concerns. You must also understand which concerns are the most important,
and address them in that order.
Once your audience actually believes you when you say that widgets are not
dangerous, they might be willing to listen to you talk about how handy they are to have
around the house.
~
~ ~ ~ ~
8. Getting
Indirect Feedback
Communication is the two-way exchange of ideas. You say something to
me and I interpret what you mean. I then say something to you and you interpret what I
mean. We continue talkingcommunicatinguntil we are done, until whatever
messages or information that needed to be transmitted or exchanged are exchanged and
hopefully understood.
During the communication process we regularly give feedback to the person
we are talking to and they give feedback to us to try to make sure we both understand what
the other is saying. To be successful and effective communicators we check and verify
each others interpretation and understanding.
When someone is reading, watching TV, or listening to a radio or TV interview,
however, there is no opportunity for any sort of direct feedback. There is no immediate
way to make sure that the message is actually getting through.
One way to overcome this problem is to build checkpoints into your writing.
When and where you insert the checkpoints will depend upon the complexity of the
material being covered and length of the writing. Are you writing a one-page news release,
two pages of instructions, a five-page letter, a 10-page report, a 20-minute speech, a
half-hour training video, or a 300-page technical manual?
Checkpoints can take many shapes and forms. They can be part of what you write, or
be included in a separate but acorganizationing piece of literature.
~
~ ~ ~ ~
9.
Getting Indirect Feedback
(Continued)
Here are some of the ways feedback can be built into a piece of writing to help
ensure that the readers, listeners, or viewers actually understand the material that is
presented to them:
·
The
piece starts with an outline of what the reader is about to read, and all of the key
points to be covered.
The point to remember is that if you are going to the trouble of presenting
information, you should take a little bit of extra time to make sure that it is best
understood by the people you are presenting it to.
~
~ ~ ~ ~
10.
Do You Speak Their Language?
Too often we assume that what is natural and normal for us is natural and normal
for everyone. This is what we mean by the COIK
(Clear Only if Known) principle. Just because
something is clear to me does not mean it will be clear to someone else.
In John Grays international best-selling book, Men Are From Mars, Women
Are From Venus, the well-known therapist and relationship counselor points out that
men and women often talk and think in two different ways. In effect, they are from two
different cultures.
With that in mind, remember that when you are communicating to your external
constituencies, you are communicating with men and womenand that they represent not
just gender differences, but in all likelihood a number of different cultures.
Culture is defined as the shared values, customs, traditions, rituals,
behaviors, and beliefs of a nation, national or ethnic group, religion, organization,
project/programme purpose, or organization.
Cultures also share languages or ways of speaking. Just because you may
speak the same language, however, does not mean that you speak it in the same way, or that
all the words in the language mean the same thing to everyone who uses them. If you have
teen-aged children, listen to the way they speak. Do you always understand what they are
really saying? Do they always understand you?
The only way to make sure that you will be understoodthat the meaning they
find in your words is as close as possible the one you put thereis to make sure that
what you say will actually be understandable by your audience. To do that you might have
to throw out your assumptions, and actually get to know and understand your audience.
1. One goal of communication strategies |
A. Confuse readers. |
2. Key to minimizing misinterpretation |
B. May cause the reader to think that you are too lazy or
ignorant to say something in an original way. |
3. Errors in writing |
C. To make sure that all the messages that are released
are structured in such a way as to reduce the possibility of misinterpretation. |
4. Jargon |
D. Make sure the meaning is obvious. |
5. Clichés |
E. Shapes current perception. |
6. History and culture |
F. Technical terms that not everyone understands. |
Answers:
1.) C
2.) D
3.) A
4.) F
5.) B
6.) E
Multiple-Choice
1. project/programme purpose should be conducted
a. With
people who understand language the same way you do
b. In
simple language
c. In technical jargon
d.
None of the above
2. The best
way to make sure that your meaning is obvious is to use
a. Careful
thought
b. Simplicity
c. Both
of the above
d. None
of the above
3.
Some people are vague because
a. They
dont know what is expected of them
b. They
are afraid of ever saying anything that takes a organization stand or position.
c. They
dont want anyone to know what is actually going on
d. None
of the above
4.
When writing, you want to
a. Avoid
treating your readers like idiots
b. Write
over your audiences head
c. Use
good vocabulary to impress your readers
d. None
of the above
5.
Some key points to know about your audience are
a. What
they know
b. What
they dont know
c. What
they are interested in
d. All
of the above
6. One way to overcome the lack of feedback in some types of communication is
a. To
build checkpoints into your writing
b. Call
everyone who views the information and ask their opinion
c. Nothing:
Feedback doesnt usually matter
d. None
of the above
7.
____________ is the two way exchange of ideas.
a. Press
releases
b. Communication
c. Email
d. Feedback
8.
The only way to make sure you will be understood is to
a. Only
talk to people that think the same way as you
b. Use
jargon to convey your message
c. Make
sure what you say will actually be understood by your audience
d. None
of the above
Summary
Sometimes languageboth spoken and writtenis misinterpreted
accidentally. Sometimes it is done on purpose. Sometimes writing is so vague and a piece
so poorly written or complicated that it is impossible to figure out exactly what the
writer was actually trying to say. While there is no guaranteed way to make sure that
nothing you write is ever misinterpreted, there are numerous ways to make it more
understandable to more people.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Test
1. ______
People do not take pride in their ability to obfuscate.
2. ______
Errors in your writing can cause readers to question or doubt everything
you say.
3. ______
While it is important to avoid jargon and use words and phrases that the people you
are addressing understand, it is not as important as to be specific and describe exactly
what you mean.
4. ______
Perception is reality even when the perception is wrong.
5. ______
Before we can communicate anything, we have to know what the people
we are trying to communicate with already know or what they dont
know and how that knowledge is getting in the way of our message.
6. ______
Past information and culture shape current perception.
7. ______
If you are going to the trouble of presenting information, it is not
necessary to put in extra time to make sure that it is best understood by the
people you are presenting it to.
8. ______
Just because two people speak the same language, does not mean that you
speak it in the same way.
9. ______
When you are communicating to your external constituencies, you are
communicating with men and women, and they represent not just gender
differences, but in all likelihood a number of different cultures.
10. ______
People know how to communicate simply.
Answers:
1. F Some people do
2.
T
3.
F It is equally important
4.
T
5.
T
6.
T
7.
F You should put in extra time to make sure
8.
T
9.
T
10.
F Many do not know how
Bibliography
Brown, J. (ed.). (1981). Jargonaphasia.
Bostrom, R. (ed.). (1984). Competence in communication: A
multidisciplinary approach.
Schiefelbusch, R., & Pickar, J. (eds.) (1984). The acquisition of communicative
competence.
Glossary
Jargon Words and phrases that is used by
groups of people that is not understood by the general public.
Communication The two way exchange of ideas.
Culture The shared values, customs,
traditions, rituals, behaviors, and beliefs of a nation, national or ethnic group,
religion, organization, project/programme purpose or organization.
Perception A persons view of
something. Perception is ones reality, even if it is wrong. Perception is shaped by
history and culture.
Learning Objectives
Q&A
1. What are
six ways to keep your writing simple?
Six ways to keep your writing simple are to be organized
and write properly. You should also avoid jargon and clichés. Use simple language, and be
as brief as possible.
2. What can
errors in your writing cause?
Errors confuse readers, make them lose their train of
thought, and detract from what you are trying to say. Errors can even cause readers to
question or doubt everything you say, even those things that are accurate.
3. What are
some ways that feedback can be built into a piece of writing?
Some ways feedback can be built into a piece of writing
are starting the piece with an outline of what the reader is about to read, and all of the
key points to be covered. It should include chapter or section headings that summarize
what is to follow. There should be regular lists of the points made and what they mean.
Each section closes with a summary. The piece includes quizzes, and the answers to the
questions and where the answers can be found in the document. In speeches, the speaker can
periodically sum up the major points they have made so far, repeat how they follow
logically, and then use them as a stepping-stone to get into the next section of the
speech. Training videos can be broken down into short modules that include summaries and
self graded tests.