The Vrinda project
Script
Pundits
MDGs presentations
Countries presentations
Episode
1 - MDG 1 - Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
1 :National Governments and International Organizations – their commitment to MDGs
in |
out |
Video |
audio |
in |
out |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:00:00 |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:00:59 |
Double screen … on the left one moving images of the work in progress by the UN … on the other still images of poverty and people in need of relief |
Introduction to the Millennium Development Goals
In September 2000, the United Nations Assembly unanimously adopted the UN Millennium Declaration. It was an 8 goal agenda that all 192 Member States agreed to adopt. We, the humanity of the third Millennium, have achieved that technological, economic and political progress from where we can no longer justify hunger and the exclusion of millions from basic health and education. In 2000, the international community acknowledged that it has a duty to recognise the fundamental rights of those who are being excluded from the benefits of progress. At the United Nations Assembly, all countries committed themselves to a work agenda that would tackle the most evident factors of poverty and injustice. They set 8 goals, they set 21 targets, they set timelines, they allocated funds: and in order to verify if they were being honest with their commitments, they set a number of indicators upon which they asked to be judged.
(music) a bit tragic , with suspense |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:00:00 |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:00:59 |
Search for them |
|
Our team getting ready?
|
And for the first time in world history, a concrete work agenda for the rights of the voiceless was universally agreed.
(shall we record it again with more energy?”
|
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:00:59 |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:01:07 |
To be recorded |
|
Vrinda facing the camera
|
from the Manual - How the Videos have been produced www.facebook.com/pages/EUGAD/211965065353
Why is it that the Millennium Development Goals, that are so important for the collective identity of our civilization, and that set the agenda of international cooperation, receive so little attention from newsmakers? Why is it that the general public is not informed about them? This is a documentary on the work in progress for the achievement of the Millennium Goals. We have travelled extensively in Asia, Africa, South America and Europe, and we have collected stories of those who design and implement international cooperation projects. Here, you will get an insight into the spirit that animates their work and you will realize what challenges they are facing on the ground. |
To be recorded |
To be recorded |
Titles
|
|||||
Europe 1/1 Bin All’ufficio di Armadilla Sequences – Edited 1 …. 00:00:00 |
……… TO BE SELECTED |
Vincenzo tells Stefano de Project priorities
… at a certain point while the audio continues the images show the group travelling (backstage) |
Backstage - Italy 1 - Armadilla Office in Rome
take the original audio from the sequence
The project we have proposed to European Union has been approved and we received the grant. Armadilla will coordinate the work. We will go in different countries to produce videos that show to the general public the work in progress for the achieving of the Millennium Goals. These videos should be innovative in their approach. Our target are the opinion makers: teachers, journalist and policy makers. We should enable them to talk to their audiences about the goals set by the United nation, the role of European Union and National Governments in achieving these goals and explain to the public the drivers of sustainable development. What is important is to bypass the usual stereotypes, record the different perspectives and give voices to the different stakeholders, including those who do not have the means to raise their voices and make their opinion heard by the big decision makers. Do not use the "pity-for-them" approach, but find an angle to narrate the stories in such a way that the people portrayed do not resent to the way you are portraying them.
To be transcripted and translated in English ! We have got an approval from the European
|
Europe 1/1 Bin All’ufficio di Armadilla Sequences – Edited 1 …. 00:00:00 |
Europe 1/1 Bin All’ufficio di Armadilla Sequences – Edited 1 …. 00:01:00 |
Da registrare o cercare |
|
Stefano travelling ..... |
from the Vrinda Project
We made this documentary because we wanted to break the stereotype that only "bad news" is really "news". It wasn't easy for us to bring the mass media gatekeepers on board the peace building adventures. But at the end, we did it. And this documentary will narrate our journey; of how we managed to bring onto the screen stories of people who are excluded and those who give voice to the excluded; stories of those who live in remote areas, far away from media spotlights. |
Da registrare |
|
Dilip Kumar | What are the factors that generate poverty? | ||||
|
Interview 3 - The factors creating
poverty The factors creating
poverty: "When we are talking about access to resources, we are talking
about access to resources that are available in the country...and
optimization of resources" What is Concern Our prime partners are the communities themselves. The entire focus of Concern is build capacities of the most vulnerable communities" |
||||
Africa MDGs - EPISODE 5 O0:07:17 |
MDGs - EPISODE 5 O0:14:50 |
Sierra Leone - Mothers Preparing Mothers - Susan and Cline Bays
more reflctions from : Manoj Kumar
|
Sierra Leone - Mothers Preparing Mothers - Susan and Cline Bays
Television cameras do not usually come here but such images are familiar to millions of us. 1 in every 3 persons in the world still lives in slums.
This is Cline Bay, a slum area situated in the heart of Freetown, the capital city of Sierra Leone, a small country off the West African coast. Cline Bay was once used as a mooring for the flotillas of the colonial powers. Now, it is home to hundreds of people who were displaced during the decades of civil war in the country and who decided to stay on even after the war was over.
Now, Cline bay is polluted. There is stagnant dirty water and uncollected garbage lying around. It is a poor neighbourhood and is crowded because it is next to a commercial area that provides opportunities for small jobs. The living conditions here are miserable and mortality rates are high, especially among infants and young mothers. But one can still feel the vibrant spirit of Africa here.
One of the major causes of poverty in Cline Bay is that girls become mothers at an early age. Besides the risk of complications, early pregnancies force girls to stop studying and instead look for jobs. And because they are not educated, they get jobs that pay very little. These young mothers also have little knowledge of child care or even basic health and hygiene, so they end up spending a large portion of their meagre earnings on medical help. Their lack of knowledge in basic health and hygiene is a major cause for their ill health. And the lack of access to good health care is the main cause for death.
We came to the slums of Cline Bay with Josephine who is a social worker in a European non-government organisation called Concern Worldwide. Concern has been working in Sierra Leone since 1996. The project that Josephine works in has been co-financed by the European Union as part of its contribution to the Millennium Development Goals. Concern implements projects funded by various international agencies and individual donor contributions.
Concern’s project in Cline Bay aims at empowering women and through them improving the lives of their families and communities. In this project, Concern works with groups of young mothers who have dropped out of school because they need to earn a living. The project being implemented by Concern aims at alleviating poverty by increasing knowledge and promoting solidarity among women who face similar challenges, problems and needs.
Josephine herself is a young mother and a school drop-out living in Cline Bay. Concern trained Josephine in the basics of health, hygiene and child care. Josephine now educates the women of Cline Bay to become more responsible mothers and teaches them safe health and hygiene practices. And she has also gone back to school once again.
She has changed her destiny and has started changing the destiny of others. She has become an active agent of change in her neighbourhood. Josephine, and her colleagues in the Concern Worldwide team, have organised Mothers’ Clubs where women teach younger mothers’ and girls in the basics of health, hygiene, and child care - like how to avoid undesired pregnancies, what is safe sex, how to take care of yourselves themselves and their children during pregnancy and after child birth. Concern Worldwide trains traditional birth attendants in pre-natal monitoring and assistance. The Mothers’ clubs promote regular check-ups and breastfeeding and run classes for ante-natal and post-natal care.
In these clubs, women share their experiences and help each other in facing the challenges of being young single mothers. The Mother’s clubs facilitate study groups, tutoring lessons and coaching programmes for girls. Their activities have led to a decrease in the school drop-out rates for girls in Cline Bay. The skills and confidence that women gain from being part of the Mothers’ Clubs also helps them participate in parent’s associations and local initiatives.
The sense of solidarity that women experience and the knowledge they acquire in these groups helps them gain courage to continue fighting poverty. Every morning young mothers living in Cline Bay leave their homes to earn their living so that their families can eat, their children can go to school and they can care for their health and that of their children. Their hope to leave the slums one day continues keeps them going.
|
MDGs - EPISODE 5 O0:07:17 |
MDGs - EPISODE 5 O0:14:50 |
|
|
|
A.K. Shiva Kumar - 1 When you talk about the MDGs you have to trace back to in the history of ideas what started in the 1990s as the idea of human development movement. So you had 10 years of a human development movement, influencing strongly the articulation of the MDGs. It was an idea promoted by UNDP, it was led by led by Prof. Amaratya Sen and the late Mahbub-ul-Haq and a lot of other social scientists. You should recall that the period 1990, or 2-3 years proceeding that, were very important years in world history. You saw the collapse of the Soviet Union, the break-up of Eastern Europe, the unification of Germany, so a lot of changes were taking place in the world. And people came to realize that all the material prosperity that you saw in terms of building in terms of comforts of living, were important but were not capturing the essence of human progress. to be better selected !
|
|
|
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:02:53 |
|
Graphics of MDG1 |
Vrinda’s voice on the MDG1 - Goal 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger The World has enough food for all but millions of people still suffer from hunger. The MDG1 aims at removing the factors responsible for poverty. Most developing countries have good rates of economic growth; but the gap between the rich and the poor is widening. The proportion of people living on less than $1 a day has decreased but 925 million people still suffer from chronic hunger. One in every four children in the developing world is still underweight. In the world, 25% people still live on less than 1.25 dollars a day. There are countries like Liberia and Sierra Leone where high percentages of the population live in misery. |
MDGs – EPISODE 1 - O0:02:53 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Da registrare o cercare |
|
Riflessioni di Stefano |
Da registrare |
|
|
Jyoti Dar Sapru | Factors which Create Poverty | ||||
|
|
What do you think are the factors which create poverty? The first two things which come to my mind, since i am in India is 'Inclusion'. What strikes me here is that even though there is a very high economic growth for many years but they do not manage to make the benefit of this growth inclusive and as a result there are 400 million people under 1 dollar a day. The second thing is education. So many people are uneducated, the illiteracy rate is quite high. In addition to this there are also so many disparities between people. There are other factors too, but inclusion and education are the most important which come to my mind.
take the original audio from the sequence
To be transcripted and translated in English ! |
|
|
|
|
|
India - Employment as a Right - Varanasi
Lalita (story of women empowerment) |
This is a typical village of northern India. More than 70% of the Indian population lives in rural areas. Many programmes of the Indian Government aim at making rural India an active part of the country’s economic growth and at helping rural communities to benefit from the fruits of development and technology.
In August 2005, the Indian government approved a job guarantee scheme called MNREGA or the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act; an Act that provides a hundred days of wage-employment per year, at 120Rs (or $2.70) per day, to rural households whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work. This Act has promoted investments in rural infrastructure projects, providing jobs to millions of Indian villagers, especially to semi or un-skilled labour that live below the poverty line and improving their purchasing power. Now, Indian villagers can stay on in their villages for at least three months in a year, reducing urban migration and precarious living. This Act is part of India’s commitment to Millennium Development Goals. Many people in rural India still do not know about this Act and lose out on earning that extra little money that can cover the basic needs of their families. Their ignorance becomes an opportunity for corruption among lower level government officers who supervise this programme.
Rekha is a social worker in an Indian non-government organisation, called Mahila Swarojgar Samiti (Women’s Self-Employment Committee). The organisation helps rural women gain economic independence by forming women’s groups, accessing income generation opportunities and advocating for their rights. Rekha informs women about their rights, helps them in accessing the rural employment scheme of the Indian government and trains them in public speaking and leadership skills. Rekha assists women in establishing and managing Self Help Groups so that they are able to use their new earning opportunity to start small business activities and cover family expenses.
The project of informing women about their rights, government programmes that benefit them, and other opportunities to earn their livelihoods has been funded by the Dorabji Tata Trust, the corporate social responsibility initiative of TATA, one of India’s largest groups of manufacturing companies. Rekha took us to one of the villages she regularly visits in the North Indian state of Uttar Pradesh and introduced us to some women who have benefitted from the Self Help Groups and the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act.
Women in this village of Uttar Pradesh are largely illiterate. Before Rekha’s organisation started working in this village, women used to manage their households and rarely work outside their homes to earn a living. Rekha and her team talked to the village women about their rights and taught them to manage small income generation activities. With the help of Rekha and her team, women established Self Help Groups. They came together as a collective and demanded their rights. They became self-confident and made their voices audible in local political processes of village panchayats, the elected bodies at the village level. They learned about government programmes and started asking for their rights. They were now able to send their children to schools, cover the health care expenses for their children and families and even buy themselves new clothes and household articles.
For the first time, women felt the joy of earning and felt empowered. They became active members of their communities. They became protagonists of their destinies and became agents of change in their homes and their communities.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
A.K. Shiva Kumar,
NREGA – It is a right and no one who goes from a poor household and says, “I
need work” can be denied work. What is distinct about the NREGA are the
clauses to ensure better governance and accountability. Social audit, which
means that it is an audit by the people of the program, is mandatory.
|
A.K. Shiva Kumar
- 2
Poverty as Income Opportunities, the Power of the MDGs & Human Rights
Discourse What is poverty? If you look at it only as income deprivation then you are missing the whole point. Because you have to look at the poverty of opportunity. We always say that income is an outcome, so if I find that this person is earning I need to know why. I have to ask the question why you are earning less and this you will always trace it back to income opportunities. Did not have adequate education, you did not have adequate command over resources, health. Examples of how development and progress is not just per capita income indicators, gdp, etc. Delhi where below poverty line is 8% but malnourishment under 5 is 33%. One of the biggest concern in Delhi is security of women (not just at night but public spaces, work place, etc.) Under 5 mortality rate is a very strong indicator of development. This depends on income but also on education. When women are literate under mortality rate drops. It depends also on the quality of water, sanitation. So when you say you will reduce under 5 mortality rate you are fundamentally talking about major changes in the standard of living. In India it is also about women position of women in society; so comes when women do paid work outside, a change in the thinking of society is created. Income gives a greater voice, changes power relations, possibility to talk to many other people. It is the opportunity that she gets with the income. What I really like about the MDGs is that it has thrown up a lot of discussions and what you find in terms of a follow through of the MDGs, is that there is no one solution. What works in Nicaragua may not work in Mexico, may not work in South Africa. Thailand said, we have already achieved Universal Education, our Mortality Rate is very low, what do you expect Thailand to do? So they launched MDG +, which said we have to achieve more. Bhutan added MDG 9 and said “zero tolerance for corruption” and they said that by 2020 Bhutan must be free from all types of corruption. So the nice thing about the MDGs was that, the UN said that all the countries must adopt it and must adapt it and localize it. So when you localize the MDGs then the debate becomes not at a global level of ideas but much more practical in terms of policies and programs and what are you doing about it. The news papers cannot just cover the growth story of India, you also have to look at what is happening to the lives of people. Can we confidently stand up and say the environment is better in India.? Can we confidently stand up and say the quality of schooling has improved? Can India confidently say that access of drinking water is much better? Because progress in society has to be measured by these indicators of human development. The other very important idea that is slowly gaining in is the idea of Human Right. When you talked about human rights the idea would focus largely on civil and political rights. But with the MDGs the economic, social and cultural rights gained importance and now they have to be put into the same level. You cannot say that economic and social rights are more important than civil and political rights. So what that you don’t have the right to vote, like in Myanmar, but the state is providing for everything… it is not, it is not sustainable. If you ask today why have many development projects or poverty alleviation projects suffered. They will tell you it was top-down and the community level, whose life it was supposed to influence and change, had very little say. There was no sense of ownership, there was no participation. So now with the Human Rights discourse , and saying that both economic and social rights, cultural right as well as civil and political have to be taken together, there is much greater recognition in the world of adopting a rights based approach to development. |
|
|
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:20:49 |
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:30:52 |
Few of us know what the Millennium Development Goals are. But people living in 26 villages of the Deogarh district in the Indian state of Jharkhand do know what these goals are. People of this village are not only aware of the MDGs but have even developed their own indicators to measure their progress in achieving the MDGs. A German non-government organisation called Welthungerhilfe implements a project in these 26 villages of Jharkhand, one of the poorest states in India. This project called “The Millennium Village” is funded by the European Commission as part of their contribution to the MDGs. It aims at raising awareness on MDGs among rural communities and at encouraging them to integrate MDGs in their development priorities and local political processes. Through this project, Welthungerhilfe also intends demonstrating a successful and replicable model of community participation where communities own and lead local development processes. We visited some of these villages with Babita who is a young social worker in Welthungerhilfe. Babita feels passionately about the importance of local communities interpreting the MDGs from the perspective of their economic, social and cultural priorities, identifying the goal and indicators that they consider coherent with their development priorities and needs and that they would like to achieve. Babita and her colleagues from Welthungerhilfe help villagers in understanding their development needs, in prioritising these needs through dialogue and consensus among themselves and in developing targets and indicators that they believe are important to achieve. The Welthungerhilfe team, together with the villagers, also tries to understand the gaps and challenges in achieving the targets that they have set for themselves. The villagers then identify projects that can address these gaps and challenges and the resources that they require in order to implement these projects. Welthungerhilfe then provides the villagers with the technical knowledge, skills and resources that they need in order to implement these projects. Mining, for instance, is the main source of income in Jharkhand and rural communities have little knowledge about agriculture. So, the villagers wanted to learn more about agriculture and start farming activities on the lands they own. Now, Welthungerhilfe trains the villagers in new farming techniques like rain water harvesting, efficient use of irrigation water, and crop rotation, in basic nutrition, health and hygiene, etc. New knowledge and specialised support is encouraging villagers to cultivate their farms and become self-reliant. Now, people can earn in the village itself. They have found a reason to stay on in their villages rather than migrate to the city. The dreams of many villagers have now become reality. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Additional Notes "Our dreams have come true. We can now stay on our farms instead of searching for jobs in the city and we can eat the healthy food we grow ", says a farmer. "If people are convinced and there is local ownership, development will take place and it will be sustainable", says the programme manager from Germany ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ It contains the interviews with:
|
|
|
|
Julian Parr |
19 - What are the Challenges for India to achieve the MDGs 1 - Importance of NGOs, their Challenges and Limitations Do you think we need NGOs to support development activities around the world? A robust civil society is hugely important in terms of democratization and hearing the voice of people. For civil society has a more inclusive definition which is not just NGOs but also Media. The freedom of press in India it's is major strength... and if you suppress the freedom of Media you suppress development. What are their Challenges? NGOs are having the define their role in a new world order, especially international NGOs. What is are role now? We cannot continue to deliver services, for in doing so they undermine the role of the Government in doing that. My own sense it that we are now moving more towards advocacy and policies and that it the role we should be playing... we should be arguing to governments like India that you should put more than just 1% of the GDP into health. What are their Challenges? Is whether they have an authentic voice. NGOs are very good in claiming to speak on behalf of people but they are not democratic institutions in their own right. I can say that, yes, we have some very robust programs on the ground, but that is because I am saying it... if I had the same response from Coca-Cola, BP, Shell or even the government, I will be very sceptical of those figures and statistics. If we are going to hold other stakeholders and other sectors into account then we ourselves have to be much more transparent and honest about our own structure. 14 - What are the factors which generate poverty? It would have to be in the context of which country. In south-east Asia and India he main factors are going to be disparity, caste, gender, class.. they are the big drivers of poverty across this whole region. 17 - Do you think availability of resources play a role in the generation or removal of poverty? Access to resources, proper policies, putting an infrastructure, putting social services, social safety nets make a huge differences. India is making some steps in the right direction specifically on MDGs on access to water. But the whole problem for the future in the whole of south Asia is going to be water |
||||
MDGs - EPISODE 1 O0:13:11 |
|
Colombia - Community at Work - Jan Pablo II ---------------
Juan
Pablo II’ Comedor Comunitario
|
|
|
|
Colombia |
|
Mercedes Del
Carmen Rios (social |
What means
participation for me?
When we talk about "social investment", we mean that "sociality" is an asset and solidarity is a capital: so the manowy spent for social welfare is not "consumed" but is invested in the gowth of our social capital.
The district administration,
specially in the
Because when somebody arrived to my
office
|
|
|
|
|
COLOMBIA - BOGOTA' - I diritti di accoglienza per i senza tetto |
A municipality that believes it has a duty of Hospitality towards its citizens who do not have a shelter. Living on the road. Many, at times, may have got into the temptation of leaving behind all ties and start anew a life from the road. Many of us host hidden fears that we may suddenly lose everyone we care for, and find ourselves on the road, with nowhere to go and no one who waits for us. In Bogotà, as in most of the big cities of the world, homeless are many; and here they are even more for the dark consequences of cheap and easy drugs, and for the regular violence to which many communities are subjected. But if you live in Bogotà, even if you are homeless, you are not without a dignified shelter.
Hogares de paso is a project of the Municipality of Bogotà for the social inclusion of those who live in the streets. Here there are many municipal “centres of passage” where the inhabitants of the streets can suspend their wanderings and re-plan their derailed lives. In these centres they get a place to sleep, to eat, to wash, to get social support. But here they would not get pity by anyone; it is their place: they have a right to it. in those weeks where the inhabitants of the streets take a break from the streets, these centres of passage are real homes, shared in dignity with others who are crossing similar stages of life.
Social workers at the centre say it out with a sense of pride: Bogotà, the city of rights. Here is a city honouring itself by taking upon itself the responsibility of hospitality of the emarginated ones.
So, in the midst of violence and poverty, many success stories do happen to the guests of these “passage centres”. Being treated as “entitles to rights” many gradually re-gain self confidence; and by interacting with the others of the centre they sometimes find new colleagues, return to their old professions, find new companions and re-establish new homes. While the city re-find confidence in itself as a strongly tied human community: we are a city “without exclusion”. |
|
|
Da registrare o cercare |
|
Riflessioni di Stefano sul rapporto tra progetti e impegno politico |
Riflessioni di Stefano – da scrivere |
Da registrare |
|
An. Kumar 2 – 08:52 |
|
Anand Kumar - 2 - The difficulty of transferring the voices of the emarginated people to the decision makers |
take the original audio from the sequence
To be transcripted and translated in English ! |
|
|
|
|
|
Why should an EU citizen fund the education of the poor children in
India? How would this benefit her?
I think that
supporting the education of a child is a wonderful objective, a wonderful
approach to defend human rights; because education is a fundamental right
of every child.
The second
element is that the money has been worth spending for in 2003 there were
25 million children out of school in India.Thanks to the program of the
Government of India and the EU in 2009 there were only 8 million children
out of school.
The third element
is that when a child is educated, when a teenage is going to college and
when out with a degree a student is getting a job; i don't think we should
think in terms of competitors. We should think in terms of wealth, in
terms of world economic growth. The more children are coming to the labor
market with a degree, with skills... then you make the world economy
run. Today there is so much interdependance between countries; it is
imprtant that there is economic growth in India and china for when our
countries are lagging behind, and when they are in the middle of a crises
it is then important that other countries are the locomotive of the
economic growth.
Whenever you give
money to somebody you have less for you; but you may have less now... but
it will bring you more tomorrow. And your child who is going to school in
europe, tomorrow might need the growth that an indian child is going to
produce.
In terms of
economic cooperation, today, we always have to look for win win
situations. |
|
|
Montek Singh Ahluwalia |
|
Why do you think certain governments are steadfast in their commitments towards MDGs while others aren't? We are committed to our goals. MDGs is an UN terminology; if you want to describe our goals as MDGs that is a different issue. I'm making this distinction because in our program we acknowledge the importance of MDGs but we don't call this a commitment because of MDGs... this has been a been part of our planning process for years. Across the world some governments are commitment some our not; in our own country also some state are committed and some are not. Ultimately in a democratic environment whatever a government does is because that is what the people who elected it wanted it to do... because if the government recognizes that if carries on doing this it won't be elected again, it won't do it |
|
|
|
Sometimes the donors should be more flexible, because the contest in Sierra Leone is a very dynamic contest and they should respect the local contest and the local reality. Donors also need to give a sufficient time to aloud the community processes, to bring the changes which are long lasting and not just a quick change and when the donors support ended those changes collapse.
Why the
process of sharing knowledge is completly lost, in evaluating the project
on the field? “There is a
lot of learning from the work of different organizations, NGO, donors,
even agencies, but there is very less of sharing those learning. Very
often you find the agencies reinventing the wills. |
|||||
|
|
How to close …. With Africa? |
from the Backstage ? Backstage - Africa 1 - Stefano e Francesco sulla spiaggia - Goal 10 - - jolly - Backstage - Africa 2 - Team Dialogues at N°2 - Goal 10 - - jolly
|
|
|
|
|