Meetings, Problem Solving and Decision Making
An important part of communicating in any organization includes the ability to use meetings effectively. This includes knowing how to plan meetings, set agendas, lead effective meetings, and be a valuable participant in meetings. One key to effective meetings is to be able to identify problems, generate alternative solutions, select the best possible solution, and carry out the tasks needed to bring that solution to fruition. Both rational and creative problem solving methods will be explored as will a variety of ways to reach decisions.
Overview
Introduction
A key tool in the communicators toolbox is the ability to use meetings effectively, all types of meetings. Meetings are often a key component in problem solving and decision-making.
A key tool in the communicators toolbox is the ability to use meetings
effectively. As we will see in this course, this includes knowing how to plan and organize
a meeting, and understanding that there are different types of meetings. Two other
key tools are problem-solving and decision-making skills.
Meetings, by their very nature, are time consuming. That time has to come out of the work day, which means that meetings can often aggravate the very problems that they are designed to solve. Many meetings are called to discuss production, performance, and other elements of getting the job done. As anyone who attends meetings knows, however, people have to set aside other aspects of their jobs in order to attend the meetings to discuss how they could get their jobs done better, more efficiently and more quickly.
In fact, a common commentoften whispered, or said under the breathis:
If I didnt have to waste so much of my work day going to so many
meetings about getting this project done, Id have this project done by now.
As we will see,
that is why it is important to make sure that meetings really
are necessary; involve only those people who really need to be there or have something
relevant to contribute; are well planned, organized and focused; stay on topic; and are as
short as possible.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
2. What This Course Will Cover
Before you can make your meetings as effective as possible, however, you have to understand the nature of meetings and how they work. Since they are usually about finding solutions to problemsor ways to avoid those problemsit is important to understand both the process of problem solving and that of decision-making.
Meetings are effective only if they achieve the goal for which they were called. With that in mind, it is obvious that people calling a meeting should have a clear understanding of just what it is they want to accomplish in that meetingand be sure that their goal is realistic.
Whats more, they have to make sure that everyone who attends has that same clear understanding.
The remaining sections of this course will deal with:
Module 2 Different Types of Meetings
Module 3 Do You Really Need a Meeting?
Module 4 Size, and Other Meeting Issues
Module 5 Planning Meetings and Setting Agendas
Module 6 Leading Meetings vs. Managing Meetings
Module 7 Being a Valuable Participant
Module 8 Meetings at Mealtime
Module 9 Meeting Dynamics
Module 10 Identifying Problems
Module 11 Gaining Support
Module 12 Turning Problems Into Opportunities
Module 13 Rational Problem Solving Methods
Module 14 Creative Problem Solving Methods
Module 15 All Meetings Are Not Created Equal
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
3.
Different Types of Meetings
There are three general types of meetings, although there is often overlap, so that few meetings are of a single type:
As the name implies, planning meetings are designed to help to prepare something for the future. This often includes the problems that people can see that might possibly develop. Planning meetings are held for reasons as diverse as getting ready for the annual office holiday party or the annual stockholders meeting, setting production quotas or sales goals, creating a budget for the next fiscal year, adopting a new bookkeeping system, or converting an assembly line to handle a new product.
Reporting meetings deal with what has been going on, what people have done, are doing now, and what they intend to be doing in the future, and where everyone stands, usually in relation to whatever the current planor problemhappens to be. The focus of this type of meeting is on sharing information.
Here again, the actual subject of the meeting can range from looking at the results of the office party or the stockholders meeting, to finding out if the production quotas or sales goals have been met, giving departments their annual budget numbers, or seeing how the new bookkeeping system and work on converting the assembly line are doing.
Reaction meetings are usually called to deal with the unexpected, such as problems with the office party, stockholders meeting, production quota, sales goals, overspending on the budget, the new bookkeeping system, or converting the assembly line.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
4. Do You Really Need A Meeting?
We have all heard that there are only two absolute certainties in life: death and taxes. As we have seen, to many in the organizational world, there is a third: meetings.
Meetings tie up time and resources, and often get in the way of completing the work that was called for by a previous meeting.
Before having a meeting, you should make sure that it is really necessary. Well look at how you can do just that. There are 10 key questions to answer before calling a meeting. They are:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
5. Size, and Other Meeting Issues
The larger a meeting is, the harder it is to accomplish anything. However, it must still be large enough to give a voice to everyone involved in the decision-making process. A meeting that is too small will have too few voices, and, as a result, it will probably produce too few suggestions. It might also engender resentment in those not included in the meeting.
In the same way that you want to keep out the people who will just be in the way at a meeting, you have to make sure that you have everyone you need.
Meetings that are too large can become unwieldy as too many people try to voice their ideas.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Effective meetings are well-planned meetingsas long as everyone in
the meeting follows the plan.
The more focused the agenda, the more likely you are to accomplish the job you need to get done.
To get a well-focused agenda, however, takes a certain amount of advance planning. Many executives say that they would rather put in extra time in planning meetingsincluding who to invite to themthan in actually attending the meeting.
Some say that a good agenda guarantees a good meetingas long as people stick to that agenda.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
6.
Leading
Meetings vs. Managing Meetings
There is a difference between leading and managing a meeting. It is the same difference between leading and managing employees, and will play a major roll in determining if the meeting participants actually make the best decisions possible.
If you are running a meeting, you have to know in advance how you will run it. Are you there as:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
People are invited to project/programme purpose meetings in order to participate in them, not just to watch. Learning how to participate in a meeting can make both you and the meeting more effective.
Learning how to be a valuable participant is like learning anything else. It takes time, effort, thought, and practice. It involves watching how other people do it, and then avoiding the mistakes that some make while emulating the successful techniques that you see others use.
Participating in meetings is as much of a skilland a highly prized one, at thatas anything else you have had to learn in order to get where you are today.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
7.
Meetings
at Mealtime
Not every meeting takes place in a conference room.
Some of the most important project/programme purpose meetings you ever attend could be over breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and can take place at a golf course, a neighborhood bar and grill, a convention center, picnic, reception, hotel, or a five-star restaurant.
Conducting yourself at an eating meeting requires good project/programme purpose skills as well as proper etiquette. You also have to realize that the definition of proper etiquette is different in different cultures and countries.
If alcohol is being served, things can get looser and friendlier and possibly, more complicated and dangerous.
There will be times in your organizational life when knowing what fork to use, what hand to hold it in, and what drink not to order, can be as important as knowing how to read a spreadsheet, prepare a budget, or run an entire division.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The nature of project/programme purpose meetings is changing. Conventional face-to-face meetings are part project/programme purpose and part social. They involve a system of group dynamics that we are all familiar with. But the new technology that is bringing us distance or electronic meetings is changing the way we have some meetings, the way we relate to the people we are meeting with, and the way we have to present ourselves.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
8. Identifying Problems
The vast majority of project/programme purpose meetings are called to solve problems. It is important to know how to identify the problems that actually need to be dealt with, since they may not always be those that you expected when the meeting started.
Quite often the problem you have called a meeting for is not really the problem that needs to be solved. The obvious or surface - problem may be the natural result of a bigger problem that has to be dealt with first.
Doctors do not automatically treat a patient in pain with pain pills. That is a symptom of the problem. Even though they will deal with the symptom, the know that their primary job is to diagnose and treat the problem that is actually causing the pain.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
There is a world of difference between just having a good idea and convincing others that it is goodeven the best one available.
In order to do this, at times, your persuasive abilities might have to be as good as your idea, maybe even better.
We will look at ways to generate support and commitment for your ideas by developing better presentation skills. While talking to 500 people in an auditorium and to seven people in a conference room can both be considered speeches, there are some important differences.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
9.
Turning
Problems into Opportunities
Every problem is an opportunity for action. Focusing on the opportunity instead of the problem can help lead to better, more creative, and more satisfying solutions.
Before you can see the opportunity that lies buried within a problem, however, you usually have to take a really close look at it, and understand the entire problem; not just the surface or obvious elements, but its root causes.
There are a number of analytical tools and methodologies that can be used on problems. We will look at them in some detail.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
It is said that if the only tool you have is a hammer, all problems begin to look like nails. Thats why its important to have more than one tool available for solving problems.
In this section we will look at a number of linear problem solving tips,
techniques, approaches, and methodologies.
We will also see that one of the most important prerequisites to solving a problem is to be able to actually state it clearly and concisely. There are many in the world of both project/programme purpose and science who believe that a problem, once clearly stated, is well on its way to being solved.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
10.
Creative
Problem Solving
Most problems can be solved with linear thinking, that is, rational problem solvingmost, but not all.
At times, however, the only solution is to turn conventional thinking upside down and try something new, something different, something creative.
Defining how to come up with why a creative idea is creative is like defining what makes a joke funny. You can do it, but the joke isnt funny anymore.
Comedy writers create laughter by looking at reality from a perspective that is not apparent to other people, and then describing what they alone can see. In the same way, creativity usually requires looking at a problem from a different angle.
Sometimes you really do have to put the cart before the horse. We will look at ways to improve creativity when trying to solve a problem.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Not All Meetings Are Created Equal
Some meetings really do require weeks of preparation and planning by a dedicated and well-coordinated team, a solid presentation, and many different contingency plans.
At other meetings you can walk in with your notes on the back of an envelope, notes you wrote in the elevator on your way to the conference room.
Earlier, we looked at different meetings in terms of their type or style. Here we will look at meetings in terms of their actual importance.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Assignments
1. Effective meetings |
A. An opportunity for action |
2. Every problem |
B. Require(s) good project/programme purpose skills and proper etiquette |
C. Change(s) the way meetings are held |
|
4. Reaction meeting |
D. Focused on surprise developments |
5. Mealtime meetings |
E. Well-planned with an agenda |
6. Electronic meetings |
F. Hard to accomplish anything |
Answers:
1.) E
2.) A
3.) F
4.) D
5.) B
6.) C
Multiple-Choice
1. Which is incorrect about meetings?
a. Theyre never a waste of time.b. They dont always include the correct participants
c. They sometimes cause problems.
d. They should be planned.
2. Which of the following are general types of meetings?
a. Reactingc. Investigating
d. Reporting
3. Which are keys to being a valuable participant at a meeting?
a. Being well-dressed.
b. Watching how others make mistakes and not copying them.
c. Knowing what the boss wants.
d. Acting very concerned even if you are bored stiff.
4. Meetings are usually called to
a. Be creative.
b.
Solve problems
c.
Complain
about the organization
d.
Please
your supervisors boss.
True /False
1._____ Some of the most important meetings could be at a golf course.
2. _____ The nature of project/programme purpose meetings havent really changed much in a long
time.
3. _____ Meetings are seldom a key component in decision making.
4. _____ Meetings are often time-consuming
5. _____ Meetings are only effective only if they achieve their stated goal.
6. _____ Planning meetings deal with whats been going on and where everyone
stands.
Answers:
1. T
2. F distance/electronic meetings have changed meetings dramatically
3. F They often provide key information.
4. T
5. F It increases the time
6. F This is a reporting meeting.
Summary
Effective meetings do not happen by accident. They are as carefully thought out, constructed, and planned as a organizations mission statement. Learning how to plan, participate in, and lead meetings are among the most important skills anyone in project/programme purpose can develop.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Test
1._____ The vast majority of project/programme purpose meetings are called to solve problems.
2. _____ All good meetings require weeks of preparation and planning.
3. _____ If you feel you need a meeting, there is no hurry to ask questions before
calling the meeting.
4. _____ A key tool in any communicators toolbox is the ability to do things on
his/her own.
5. _____ Many meetings are a waste of time.
6. _____ Effective meetings always reach their desired goal.
7. _____ If your departments production goals are unexpectantly doubled, you
should hold a Reporting meeting
8. _____ Every problem is an opportunity to look good to the boss.
9. _____ One of the most important prerequisites to solving problems is to clearly
define it.
10. _____ Problems are like jokes.
Answers:
1. T
2. T
3. T
4. F its the ability to use meetings effectively
5. T
6. T
7. F a Reaction meeting
8. F its an opportunity for action
9. F like in comedy, looking at problems from a different perspective can often help
10. T
Bibliography
How to Make Meetings Work, by Michael Doyle and
David Straus, Berkeley Publishing Group, 1993.
Great Meetings: How to Facilitate Like a Pro, by
Dee Kelsey et al.,
Meeting of the Minds, by Daniel Iacofano, MIG
Publications, 2001.
Glossary
Effective meetings Meetings that are well planned and organized, that are focused and stay on the topic, have an agenda, and reach some pre-determined goal.
Agenda A meeting document that details the topics to be covered in a meeting and the approximate time to cover them.
Distance or electronic meeting A meeting where not all the participants are physically present
Meeting types Meeting types are generally classified as Planning, Reacting, and Reporting
Learning Objectives
Ø An effective meeting meets a pre-determined goal
Ø Meetings can be of various types, and different methods will be appropriate depending on the type of meeting you hold.
Q&A
1. How do I know if I really need to hold a meeting?
There are many questions to ask yourself before calling a meeting. These may include:
Ø Defining what you want to accomplish
Ø What information is already available
Ø How much time will it take
Ø Who can help solve the problem, and so on.
If it is a complex problem spanning multiple departments, or whose solution will effect many other people, you may need to call a meeting.
2. What sort of issues should a meeting cover?
Meetings may cover a variety of issues and solutions. If you want to propose something for the future, you call a PLANNING meeting. If you want to find out the current status of an issue or problem, you call a REPORTING meeting. If you want to get feedback on a new or unexpected issue, call a Reacting meeting.
3. How can meetings solve problems?
They can get everyone involved. By participating in a meeting, employees can bring new insights into complex issues. "Obvious" problems may just be symptoms of larger problems. Different people often see different solutions, and some people can be very creative in solving problems. Also by involving many different people, you usually obtain better results and gain more support.